Saturday, November 7, 2020

Setting up Cowpens

 



  Cowpens is one of the more interesting actions fought during  the  American Revolution.  General Daniel Morgan with a mismatched command won one of the most decisive battles of the war.  He understood how his opponent Banastre Tarleton fought and designed his battle plan for him.  He understood the various strengths and weakness of each of his troop types (rifles, Continental line regulars and militia) and set them to maximize their strengths not their weaknesses.
It is also one of the best preserved battlefields I have visited.  

In fighting this out on the table top I will be using  the historical order of battle at a 1:10 scale.  The rules used are "Whites of Their Eyes" by Steve Haller.  I am limiting the game to 12 turns.  This is to force the British to rush into the fight as historically they did.  The battlefield was very slight rolling ground.  There were scattered trees, mostly pines but they did not effect the fighting.  Here are a couple pictures from the actual battlefield to show how it looks.





The Americans are set up with the cavalry hidden in a swale along one edge of the field.  The American main line of Continental line troops is 15 inches from them.  A line of two militia regiments are 10 inches in front of them with another line of rifles 10 inches in front if them.  The plan was for each line to cause casualties before falling back.  The British will enter the board in two lines.  The first is made up of the 7th Regiment, Royal Artillery (3 pounder), British Legion Infantry and Light Infantry battalion.  A troop of the Legion Cavalry and 17th Light Dragoons protect each flank.  On turn 3 the remainder of the British Legion Cavalry and 1/71st Highlanders enter.  The British must attack and destroy the enemy as quickly as possible.




A hidden advantage of the game is the American command structure.  Morgan is the commander, assisted by Howard who commands the Continentals and Pickens who commands the Militia.  The British have only Tarleton.  This will effect starting troops and assisting with close combat and rallying routed troops.  So it will be a difficult battle for the British to win.


Cowpens Order of Battle

Morgan's Light Division

Cavalry Brigade: Lt. Col.Wm Washington
Continental Light Dragons (8) (regulars)
McCall's Militia Horse (6) (militia)

Continental Brigade: Col. Howard
Maryland-Delaware Light bn. (24) (elite)
VA. State Troops (12) (regulars)
Tripplett's VA. Rifles (12). (regulars)


Militia Brigade: Pickens
1st Spartan SC militia. (24 (militia)
2nd Spartan SC militia (24)  (militia)
(Hays Little River Militia Divided between the two militia regiments)
McDowell's Rifles. (12)  (militia)
Cunningham's Rifles (12) (militia)

(134 figures)






Tarleton's Flying Column
Lt. Col. Tarleton commanding

17th LD troop (4)
British Legion Troop (4) (regulars)
Royal Artillery 3pounder (regulars)
British Legion Infantry (20) (regulars)
British Light Infantry (16) (regulars)
7th Fusiliers (18) (regulars)
1/71st Highlanders (24) (regulars)
British Legion  Dragoons (20)  (militia)
(106 figures)

(Light bn made up of light companies 71st regiment, and companies from the 16th Regiment and Prince of Wales American Regiment. A most unusual unit indeed!)

4 comments:

  1. It will be interesting to see how this goes Mark - Banastre Tarleton was a bit too impetuous for an independent field command in my opinion and this was shown up in this engagement. I am picking your refight will have a similar outcome to the original!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am afraid if you fight it as the historical battle it is a forgone conclusion. Morgan knew his enemy and planned accordingly.

      Delete
  2. Cowpens is interesting, being one of the AWI battles with the most cav, and is almost always one of the first two or three games I try with a new set of AWI rules.

    A couple of things I noticed WRT the British OB:
    1) It lists "17th LD troop (4)" but doesn't show their quality/morale grade. Presumably regulars?
    2) Next it lists "British Legion Troop (4) (regulars)", and at the bottom it lists "British Legion Dragoons (20) (militia)". Since I believe the former is just a small detachment from the latter, it seems odd they are of different quality/morale grade. Is that a mistake, or was it intentional (e.g. based on their numbers)?

    I always find the rating of the British Legion Dragoons in rules/scenarios interesting. I've seen them rated "regular", which always struck me as a bit generous. I've also seen them rated somewhere between "regular" and "militia", if it's available in a particular set of rules. I don't know that I've seen them rated "militia" before, but if there is no alternative between "regular" and "militia"...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope this answers your questions,

      "A couple of things I noticed WRT the British OB:
      1) It lists "17th LD troop (4)" but doesn't show their quality/morale grade. Presumably regulars?"

      The 17th Light Dragons should have been rated as elite. Although a very small troop they performed well during the battle considering the numbers of horse brought against them.

      2) Next it lists "British Legion Troop (4) (regulars)", and at the bottom it lists "British Legion Dragoons (20) (militia)". Since I believe the former is just a small detachment from the latter, it seems odd they are of different quality/morale grade. Is that a mistake, or was it intentional (e.g. based on their numbers)?

      The British Legion had been vastly increased numbers wise after the Battle of Camden by recruiting Continentals prisoners. Join the legion or off to the prison hulks! Check out how many men Tarleton had at each battle and you see where I am coming from. This effected the performance of the Legion at Cowpens, and not for the better. there are reports of these ex prisoners returning to the Continental ranks after Cowpens. Also note that the small troop on the left flank fought welluntill overwhelmed. The main body of Legion dragons refused to charged. Because of this I rated for this game the main body as militia horse and the small troop as regular. for more about thus may I suggest the essay in the legion Cavalry and Continental prisoners in Jim Piecuch's book Cavalry in the American Revolution.

      I always find the rating of the British Legion Dragoons in rules/scenarios interesting. I've seen them rated "regular", which always struck me as a bit generous. I've also seen them rated somewhere between "regular" and "militia", if it's available in a particular set of rules. I don't know that I've seen them rated "militia" before, but if there is no alternative between "regular" and "militia"…

      In the rules I used cavalry are rated as Elite, Regular and Militia. I assigned these ratings based on the historical performance of the units during that battle.

      To me, the key to this fight is the command structure. Tarleton is by himself. Morgan has good subordinate commanders.

      Mark

      Delete